Does Dieting Contribute to the Development of Binge Eating Disorder?

Does Dieting Contribute to the Development of Binge Eating Disorder

The relationship between dieting and binge eating disorder (BED) is intricate and multifaceted. While dieting is often viewed as a way to achieve weight loss and improved health, research by Goldschmidt, A. B. suggests dieting may paradoxically increase the risk of developing binge eating disorder (BED).

The intricate dynamics of the Binge-Restrict Cycle reveal how dietary restrictions can lead to feelings of deprivation, ultimately resulting in episodes of uncontrollable binge eating. Understanding the complex interplay between dieting and binge eating is essential for developing effective treatment strategies and promoting healthier relationships with food.

Can Dieting Cause Binge Eating Disorder?

Yes, dieting can potentially contribute to the development of binge eating disorder (BED), but the relationship is complex and not straightforward. Historically, it was believed that dietary restraint could lead to binge eating behaviors. 

According to Goldschmidt, A. B.’s 2012 study, ‘Which dieters are at risk for the onset of binge eating? ‘ A prospective study of adolescents and young adults’, found that dieters were 2–3 times more likely to develop binge-eating problems than non-dieters over the five-year follow-ups. Additionally, depression symptoms and self-esteem were significant predictors of binge-eating onset, independent of dieting. Detrimental levels of these psychosocial factors among dieters increased the likelihood of binge eating, particularly in the later follow-up period.

How Does Restrictive Eating Contribute to Bingeing?

Restrictive eating practices, like fasting or skipping meals, can increase the risk of binge eating, particularly when combined with a recent history of bingeing.

According to De Young KP,’s study, ‘Bidirectional associations between binge eating and restriction in anorexia nervosa. An ecological momentary assessment study’, the relationship between restrictive eating and binge eating is complex and multifaceted. In individuals with anorexia nervosa, behaviors such as going extended periods without eating can create a cumulative risk for subsequent binge episodes, especially following recent binge eating. Interestingly, while skipping meals may lower the likelihood of same-day bingeing, the overarching dynamics suggest that restrictive practices can trigger a cycle of disordered eating. 

Understanding these interactions is crucial for developing effective treatment strategies to address both binge and restrictive eating behaviors in clinical settings.

What is The Binge-Restrict Cycle?

The Binge-Restrict Cycle

The Binge-Restrict Cycle is a pattern of disordered eating behavior characterized by alternating periods of restrictive dieting and episodes of binge eating. This cycle typically begins with self-imposed dietary restrictions that lead to feelings of deprivation, followed by uncontrollable binge eating episodes where large quantities of food are consumed. 

After bingeing, individuals often experience guilt and shame, prompting a return to restrictive eating behaviors, thus perpetuating the cycle. This pattern can have negative physical and psychological effects, including weight fluctuations, nutritional deficiencies, and increased anxiety related to food and body image.

This cycle typically involves the following stages:

  1. Restriction: The individual imposes strict dietary rules or limitations on themselves, often in an attempt to lose weight or control their eating habits. This can lead to feelings of deprivation.
  2. Bingeing: Eventually, the feelings of deprivation and hunger can become overwhelming, leading to episodes of binge eating, where the individual consumes large amounts of food in a short period, often feeling a loss of control during these episodes.
  3. Guilt and Shame: After bingeing, individuals often experience feelings of guilt, shame, or regret about their eating behavior. This can reinforce negative self-perceptions and lead to further restrictive behaviors.
  4. Return to Restriction: In response to the guilt and the desire to regain control, the individual may return to restrictive eating patterns, thus restarting the cycle.

This cycle can be harmful both physically and psychologically, leading to a range of issues including nutritional deficiencies, weight fluctuations, and increased anxiety or depression related to food and body image. Breaking the Binge-Restrict Cycle often requires a shift in mindset towards a more balanced and intuitive approach to eating, as well as addressing any underlying emotional or psychological issues.

What Are the Consequences of Chronic Dieting?

negative consequences of Chronic dieting

Chronic dieting can lead to several negative consequences, including weight gain in the long term, the development of eating disorders, and negative psychological effects. It may also have physical impacts, although these are less conclusive and require further study.

According to Memon AN’s 2020 study, ‘Have Our Attempts to Curb Obesity Done More Harm Than Good? Cureus.’, dieting has significant psychological consequences, often leading to depression, emotional distress, and a preoccupation with food. Chronic dieters exhibit behaviors similar to those with eating disorders, such as bulimia (8.4%-19.4% prevalence in women) and anorexia, suggesting psychological deprivation akin to starvation. 

This study also indicates that dieters often ignore natural hunger cues, making them susceptible to binge eating, particularly after high-calorie foods.

Is There a Healthier Alternative to Dieting?

Healthier Alternative to Dieting

The common healthier alternatives to dieting include intuitive eating, Health at Every Size (HAES), and mindful eating, which focus on nourishing your body rather than restricting food intake. Consider these strategies:

Intuitive Eating: This approach encourages listening to your body’s hunger and fullness cues instead of following external rules. Tuning in may lead to more satisfying food choices and a different relationship with food.

Health at Every Size (HAES): HAES emphasizes overall well-being regardless of weight. It focuses on self-care and self-acceptance, shifting attention from the scale to body image and recognizing that health can be viewed in various ways.

Mindful Eating: Mindful eating invites slowing down and savoring food. This practice involves paying attention to the eating experience and recognizing physical and emotional needs.


Share This Post

Related Articles

Start Your Journey to Wellness Today

Are you ready to take the next step towards better mental health? Los Angeles Outpatient Center (LAOP) is here to support you on your journey to recovery. Our comprehensive programs, experienced team, and welcoming environment are designed to provide the care you need.

Contact us today to schedule an initial assessment or to learn more about our services. Whether you are seeking intensive outpatient care or simply need guidance on your mental health journey, we are here to help.

Contact Us